Partickger
Well-Known Member
Would be interesting to see another table showing who has benefited the most.
No prizes for guessing!
No prizes for guessing!
Or who was the ref and VAR team on each occasion of our incidents?Best stat to look at to see a ref’s performance in a game imo is the fouls to booking ratio for each team. Guess which team almost always comes out miles ahead.
Nah all is well in the world again now that the filth are back top.
All the chatter about officials literally disappeared the day Ross County beat us.
The club should be highlighting this and calling out. It's clear what is going on in this corrupt backwater of a league. I suspect we will be adding a few more to that total in the coming weeks...especially after we play at Torbett Towers.Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:
Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
Kilmarnock 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Ross County 0
Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.
It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.
The reality is massively different.
Yeah, these things even themselves out. Except they really don't!Season after season.
Oh! And next season too.
But it's just a coincidence.
In OF games factually we do not get the benefit of crucial goal deciding decisions.Even when repeatedly presented with irrefutable proof of the loaded dice we are up against, season after season, some just think that refs and officials are " incompetent. "
In OF games factually we do not get the benefit of crucial goal deciding decisions.
All one way.
The only big decision I can remember going in our favour was the Silva penalty which was a penalty.
Contrast with Morelos goal and Dessers non foul incident when Roofe scored.
Collum managing to circumvent procedure as the VAR man.(I know it was offside anyway but he didn’t know at the time)
Dessers goal last game when brought back to inside our half for a foul.
In summary we don’t get benefit of the doubt.
Now there's a shockerooni for you!Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:
Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
Kilmarnock 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Ross County 0
Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.
It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.
The reality is massively different.
When that is added to the 9? penalties not given by referees but reluctant VARs the bias against Rangers amongst referees is clear. Inquiry required.Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:
Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Kilmarnock 0
Ross County 0
Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.
It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.
The reality is massively different.
Have we not had something like 10 penalties given after VAR review on their own?
I assume this is for ones that we didn’t get or were wrongly given against us.
How much kudos does the sfa give to the IRP?Also both us and Dundee had a red card that was given on the pitch, sent to the monitor by VAR, then confirmed by the ref, appealed by the club, then confirmed again by the SFA. These were determined to be incorrect decisions by the review.
Is there a list of these decisions?Wonder how many of the wrong decisions against other teams involved Celt*c ?
Best stat to look at to see a ref’s performance in a game imo is the fouls to booking ratio for each team. Guess which team almost always comes out miles ahead.
Funny thatAye, but theirs are soft fouls in Scotland, apparently, and not worthy of bookings.
In Europe, strangely enough, they average roughly the same fouls per card as us.
What decision? The boot to the face is a red card all day every day and the penalty if I remember correctly was a stonewaller.Is the Celtic decision in the game vs. Hearts?
If so, they got a penalty that wasn’t to negate the decision against them.
The he club should be highlighting this throughout it's social media channels.Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:
Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Kilmarnock 0
Ross County 0
Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.
It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.
The reality is massively different.
Clancy and Collum are cheating bastards mate.I dont think refs are bent. Never have. Wouldn’t renew my season ticket if i believed the game was a done deal etc. I also dont believe their is a pro killie or anti st mirren bias either. . But, had celtic been the team the most hard done by and us down the bottom, their fans would have been tweeting the fbi, writing to mps and requesting audiences at the vatican. It highlights the insanity of not just their fans, but any team thinking refs deliberately favour us.
Don't know mate, but with VAR we would have won a title under Gio, fact.What would the league table look like without those errors?
I’m past the data. It’s as predictable as the sun rising in the East.The he club should be highlighting this throughout it's social media channels.
Well I am SHOCKED. Not.Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:
Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Kilmarnock 0
Ross County 0
Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.
It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.
The reality is massively different.
Oh they are very capable of making decisions alright but some are scared to make the right decisions where Celtic are concerned and others for their bias!No surprise there. And even before VAR we were the team most wronged i expect.
The thing that strikes me is what the hell is this actually telling us - is it that our officials are so incapable of making correct decisions , even with tech to help them?
IF this is meaningful data, with a purpose, then surely the next action would be for those VAR experts/refs to declare why the are making wrong decisions.
Best stat to look at to see a ref’s performance in a game imo is the fouls to booking ratio for each team. Guess which team almost always comes out miles ahead.
How do you explain those figures then? Just coincidence?I dont think refs are bent. Never have. Wouldn’t renew my season ticket if i believed the game was a done deal etc. I also dont believe their is a pro killie or anti st mirren bias either. . But, had celtic been the team the most hard done by and us down the bottom, their fans would have been tweeting the fbi, writing to mps and requesting audiences at the vatican. It highlights the insanity of not just their fans, but any team thinking refs deliberately favour us.
Also be interesting to see these wrong decisions and how many times Celtic were the opponent / beneficiaryIncorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:
Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Kilmarnock 0
Ross County 0
Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.
It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.
The reality is massively different.
So what were Radio Clyde referring to last night? They kept saying St Mirren were hardest done by with these calls with most incorrect decisions against them.
A combination of that and incompetence. I dont think their is a pro-killie bias across scottish refs either. Nor do I think there is a conspiracy against st mirren.How do you explain those figures then? Just coincidence?
Surely it’s the case that these penalties should have been given by the match referee aren’t due to official and press intimidationHave we not had something like 10 penalties given after VAR review on their own?
I assume this is for ones that we didn’t get or were wrongly given against us.