Manager of the year nominees Mccinnes Tony Docherty and John McGlynn

[ThreestripeS]

Doing these awards before the season is over is so utterly ridiculous. If Clement wins the treble then he's clearly a million percent the manager of the year. Otherwise, it is McInnes.

Why is it mciness why is it got to be a spfl manager?

 

[CalvinBassey55]

Yeah, no progress at all. Would have been as well sticking with Beale. As stupid posts go on here, that one is particularly stupid. And that's saying something. Well done.

Thank you Big D. No doubt your a genius. Since Clements came in we've won a final we were expected to win, still not won an old firm game that matters, threw away the league and champions league money. Also handed out new records to Ross county, Motherwell and Dundee. But apart from that you're spot on. 2nd is last.

 

[kilbirnie bear]

Finishing 6th with Dundee is Manager of the Year material?

Only in the SPL would this happen

 

[Camby loyalist]

No he isn't. He's 5 games away from a possible treble.

Even if we win all our league games it guarantees absolutely nothing in terms of the title. Seeing a lot of this bullshit on here - we fucked it.

From where we were in October Clement has done an amazing job with the sh*te he was left, some people forget this.

 

[Camby loyalist]

Thank you Big D. No doubt your a genius. Since Clements came in we've won a final we were expected to win, still not won an old firm game that matters, threw away the league and champions league money. Also handed out new records to Ross county, Motherwell and Dundee. But apart from that you're spot on. 2nd is last.

I smell something fishy here.

 

[derek145]

Clement winning a treble and someone else named manager of the year would be peak Scottish football

In 2008, we were 1 league game away from the Treble and lost in the Uefa Cup final and they gave the managers award to Billy Reid in the 1st division

 

[strider]

John mcglynn is going for an unbeaten season and people greeting about dundee

I think he is the front runner personally.

Docherty is in his debut season as a manager, with a team that got promoted last season so were one of the favourites to be in a relegation fight, and could get them into Europe if results go their way. I don't think his nomination is that surprising.

Clement would be a worthy shout, and there's an argument for Naismith as well.

 

[jigster]

plastic pitch
shite pitch
plastic pitch

 

[lou riccios chipshop]

Naismith has only been Hearts manager for half the season.

 

[Professor Yaffle]

I thought yon sheep Robson done awfy good

 

[Professor Yaffle]

The St Mirren manager has done better than the Dundee guy.

 

[HandsomeHead]

Clement not even getting a nomination despite where we were when he took over is a fucking joke tbh.

Absolutely. Turned around an 8 point defecit to have us neck and neck with the Beasts going into the final handful of matches; lifted the only piece of silverware up for grabs to date, and took us into the knockout stages of Europe once again.

But nah, Tony Doc pips him to a spot for managing to squeeze Dundee into the top six?

Aye, okay then.

(PS: I’ve no idea who John McGlyn is)

 

[pandager1]

Docherty had only a handful of senior players under contract when he became manager. He's done a phenomenal job there.

Him or McInnes would deserve it.

 

[niallmitch]

Walter won the double once and the Hamilton manager got the manager of the year .

This, even Billy Reid said it was nonsense

 

[Diego Maradona]

Just win the treble Phil.

Love it when they give man of the match to someone and then another player gets a hat trick

 

[ibrox1975]

Clement not even getting a nomination despite where we were when he took over is a fucking joke tbh.

It could be argued he’s only been with us for 6 months.
I’m genuinely surprised he’s not at least in the running however these awards are not really worth having.

 

[steven allen]

Must be the first time in awhile both old firm managers aren't up for it

https://twitter.com/x/status/1785238066099069223

Meanwhile the only manager in the country that's

Won a trophy
Reached another cup final
Reached the last 16 in Europe
Has a chance of winning the league

Is not considered!!
This country is mental!!

 

[Corporal Jones]

We were 2nd before Clement came in and we're still 2nd.

We were 2nd before Clement came in and we're still 2nd.

Statements like this is why you were sold to ajax

 

[BSPECIAL]

Clement not even getting a nomination despite where we were when he took over is a fucking joke tbh.

And a potential treble on the way

 

[valencia05]

John McGlynn? Pretty random

Why not Rhys McCabe at Airdrie? Won a trophy already this season and in play-offs for Premiership after one season in Championship

 

[Davieblue1977]

Got to be McInnes

Would think so

 

[kirkwinningblue]

Must be the first time in awhile both old firm managers aren't up for it

https://twitter.com/x/status/1785238066099069223

Ridiculous that nominees out so early, Phillipe cud grab a treble ffs

 

[gersrus71]

Clement winning a treble and someone else named manager of the year would be peak Scottish football

Did that not happen with Walter? Can’t remember if he won a treble or it was the season he took us to UEFA final but he ended up getting overlooked for Billy Reid at Hamilton.
Something rings a bell about it.

 

[Albertz Loyal]

Clement not even getting a nomination despite where we were when he took over is a fucking joke tbh.

Imagine the wins the treble

 

[EddiBrock]

McGlynn should be favourite

Who does he manage?

 

[EddiBrock]

Mcglynn should get it on probably 100th of the wages we or the bheasts pay out.
Unbeaten in the league well deserved

OK. Ignore my last post

What league are Falkirk now? Championship? League 1?

 

[EddiBrock]

Thank you Big D. No doubt your a genius. Since Clements came in we've won a final we were expected to win, still not won an old firm game that matters, threw away the league and champions league money. Also handed out new records to Ross county, Motherwell and Dundee. But apart from that you're spot on. 2nd is last.

They all matter

Call of the mhanks

Called yourself out there

Or just too dumb to have your own thoughts

 

[EddiBrock]

I smell something fishy here.

Something shitey

 

[LarkfiedLoyalNS]

Since Billy Reid got it in 2008 it’s not something I take serious and nobody should it’s a joke of an award.

 

[MartinS93]

Had to Google who tf John McGlynn is tbh.

 

[Texas ranger]

Walter being snubbed when taking us to a European final will never be topped. I'm sure MOTY went to the Hamilton Accies gaffer.

And as an award, never to be taken seriously afterwards.

Let’s face it! It’s a joke. Like much of everything else that goes on in Scottish football.

 

[jigster]

John McGlynn? Pretty random

Why not Rhys McCabe at Airdrie? Won a trophy already this season and in play-offs for Premiership after one season in Championship

Because Airdrie don't have Bronze level ......

 

[Noddy]

Has anybody mentioned that Walter Smith was going for a treble and reached a European final, but they gave it to Billy Reid of Hamilton?

 

[AchtungBaby]

Clement came in and got us playing well but if you look at the money spent and expected outcome, 2nd is the least we should be, so in a sense he's done exactly what was expected. Mcinnes had taken a team that were in the Championship 2 years ago and got them comfortably into the top 4 and beaten all the better teams in the league work a pittance of a budget. It's a no-brainer.

 

[Noddy]

John McGlynn? Pretty random

Why not Rhys McCabe at Airdrie? Won a trophy already this season and in play-offs for Premiership after one season in Championship

He's went through the season unbeaten.

 

[MaxMK]

Clement not even getting a nomination despite where we were when he took over is a fucking joke tbh.

Yip - he has taken us to two cup finals - won one and still one to play. He’s clawed back 7 points in the league to keep it alive until the end of season. He’s done fantastic in the short time he had been here and to be overlooked is a joke

 

[MaxMK]

Yip - he has taken us to two cup finals - won one and still one to play. He’s clawed back 7 points in the league to keep it alive until the end of season. He’s done fantastic in the short time he had been here and to be overlooked is a joke

Sorry also last 16 of Europe.

 

[Davie Weir]

John McGlynn? Pretty random

Why not Rhys McCabe at Airdrie? Won a trophy already this season and in play-offs for Premiership after one season in Championship

Taken Falkirk up when they’ve been stuck in league one for 5 (I think) years. On track for an unbeaten season and if they win their last game will finish on 97 points.

 

[JMCK]

McInnes has done really well at Kilmarnock since he went there, and deserves it. Quite underrated as well.

 

[blue diesel]

My take,
Clement and rodgers were not nominated
because there giving it to docherty.
Soon it will get harder to attract bigger names to that club
after all the court cases come out
So when they punt rodgers,
They need someone who will protect the image of that dump,
and calm the baying tramps.
And who better than the manager of the year.

 

[Davie Weir]

OK. Ignore my last post

What league are Falkirk now? Championship? League 1?

Currently league one but they’ve won that so will be promoted to the championship

 

[SIRBLUE]

It's amazing how people can't understand the difference in aspirations that apply to a Rangers manager as opposed to Dundee, Falkirk or Kilmarnock.
Docherty has worked wonders with a squad that makes the one PC inherited look like Brazil 1970, and McGlynn has his team unbeaten in the league all season.
Both have achieved what they have with no budget whatsoever.
This is the criteria applied, not who wins the most between Rangers and Celtic.
It's not really difficult this.

 

[A Magician Named Gob]

These have always been fairly worthless while there are things to be played for.

 

[Stuart pid]

Why do they always do it so early?

You could have a situation where Clement wins a treble but Tony Docherty finishing 6th could get MOTY?

Same with our player awards. Tav gets the golden boot but could easily be overtaken by Dessers.

 

[Brahim Hemdani's Granny]

If Clement can win us a treble, I doubt him, or us, will be giving a toss about these tinpot awards.

Never understood why they award them with so many games to go anyway. It's also a bit strange to compare a manager in League One with those in the SPL.

 

[aye me]

There should be a special award for the Dundee groundsman tosser of the season

 

[KensingtonBlue]

Docherty's only credentials are that he's a Rangers hating scumbag

So he'll probably win it

 

[madride]

Thank you Big D. No doubt your a genius. Since Clements came in we've won a final we were expected to win, still not won an old firm game that matters, threw away the league and champions league money. Also handed out new records to Ross county, Motherwell and Dundee. But apart from that you're spot on. 2nd is last.

Play down a trophy we’ve actually won with a snidey remark.

Concede the league that we can still win.

What a joyless fking existence

 

[Bill the Butcher]

Clement not even getting a nomination despite where we were when he took over is a fucking joke tbh.

Could win a treble and not be nominated.

 

[JeffreySpauIding]

Clement not even getting a nomination despite where we were when he took over is a fucking joke tbh.

Not going to get a nomination after chucking the league away against Motherwell, Dundee and Ross County.